Wednesday 20 November 2013

The testosterone factor in home education



One of the things which one noticed during most of the recent history of home education, is that it was dominated by women. This was perhaps only natural; anything to do with raising children has always been viewed as a naturally feminine matter. Men were few and far between on the British home educating scene until the beginning  of the present  century. At about this time, men like Ian Dowty and Mike Fortune-Wood began to become well-known in some home educating circles. Contemporaneously and possibly coincidentally, this was the very time that serious confrontation also became a notable feature of the home education in this country. Before that time, the default setting for parents was allowing local authority officers to visit their homes, speak to their children and look through the child’s work.  From roughly 2000 onwards, a trend developed strongly in some quarters which was opposed to local authorities having anything much to do with home educating families. A mood of bellicosity and confrontation began to replace the generally easy-going relationships which had previously characterised  home education.

Commenting here a few days ago, somebody hinted that there might be a direct causal link between certain men becoming involved in home education and the air of tension and confrontation which we now see. This is an interesting hypothesis. Women who worked in nursing during the 1970s and 1980s noticed very clearly the effect of men getting mixed up in what was before that an almost exclusively female domain. For one thing, they tend to take over and for another, the whole atmosphere of the profession changed subtly. Where women tend often to work cooperatively, avoiding conflict where possible; men simply thrive upon confrontation and argument. I wonder if something along these lines could be at work in home education? One of the largest internet lists is run by a man; Mike Fortune-Wood’s HE-UK list. This list has  been enormously active and the posters tremendously aggressive at various times, such as in 2009, during the Badman business. A lot of campaigning was loosely coordinated here. Mike Fortune-Wood encourages this list to be in opposition to any cooperation with local authorities, by banning those whose views do not agree with his own hard line and imposing moderation on others, to prevent more moderate voices from being heard. In other words, he shapes it in his own, masculine, image.  Ian Dowty’s influence has also been towards opposition to local authorities, rather than consensus. Being a barrister has given him a lot of clout in this respect.

This is only a tentative idea, but a rather interesting one. Relations between home educators and local authorities can be pretty delicate at times and I have yet to encounter any situation which is improved by the addition of half a bucket of testosterone. The more cynical among my readers might even be prompted to speculate upon the extent that I too might perhaps be a part of this syndrome, if it exists.

19 comments:

  1. What about the LA officers who dealt with HE; what was the balance between men and women in, say the 1970s-1990s, and what is it now?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 'What about the LA officers who dealt with HE; what was the balance between men and women in, say the 1970s-1990s, and what is it now?'

      That's an interesting point. My impression is that they were and are, nearly all women. Oddly enough, the one local authority officer in this role in Essex, Mike Allpress, was also the only one to whom I ever heard anybody object. I'm sure we've also all heard of Tony Mooney! Maybe the trouble is caused generally by men; whichever side of the fence they happen to be on?

      Delete
    2. Webb says "Maybe the trouble is caused generally by men; whichever side of the fence they happen to be on?"

      Old Webb has a point here females tend to avoid conflict and resolve issues it should also be noted that many of the senior staff in LA's are men! and most county councilors who these officer report to are men to.

      Delete
    3. Finally, a good point from Mr Williams.

      Delete
    4. are you affording me a gold star?

      Delete
    5. 'Affording' ?

      Delete
    6. yes buying me one you sound like a teacher in a state school

      Delete
    7. I'm not, but I believe that they don't do that any more. However, I'm sure you can draw one for yourself.

      Delete
    8. i am rubbish at drawing!

      Delete
  2. 'Where women tend often to work cooperatively, avoiding conflict where possible;'
    Except on facebook, of course.

    ReplyDelete
  3. 'A lot of campaigning was loosely coordinated here.''

    Not much though. Most of that was done on BRAG. Until M F-W found it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Don't forget Mr Taylor-Moore.

    ReplyDelete
  5. 'Don't forget Mr Taylor-Moore.'
    Ah yes, Neil Taylor-Moore, the other double-barreled name that somebody was enquiring about. The one who is a believer in many peculiar conspiracy theories; including some with a distinctly anti-Semitic flavour.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sssshhh...don't mention the Rothschilds...

      Delete
    2. 'Sssshhh...don't mention the Rothschilds...'

      Yes, I feel a post coming on about well-known people on the British home education scene who are believers in the New World order. I have mentioned one such recently.

      Delete
  6. "Commenting here a few days ago, somebody hinted that there might be a direct causal link between certain men becoming involved in home education and the air of tension and confrontation which we now see."

    The article, What's Wrong With Home Visits?
    Why you might want to choose some other method of providing evidence to your local education authority
    , was written by a woman two years before Mike FW started his web site.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There were always people pushing for that approach. It just didn't become a widespread truism for a few years after that.

      Delete
    2. Ah yes, the connection between Sarah Fitz-Claridge of TCS and the Fortune-Woods is certainly worth exploring. Jan Fortune-Wood is a follower and devotee of Taking Children Seriously. It was once her husband got involved that the thing really got going among home educators.

      Delete
    3. " It was once her husband got involved that the thing really got going among home educators."

      But you've only mentioned those who are still active in HE forums now. What about the home educators who were as or even more active in the 90's than the ones you are discussing? I can remember several names off-hand, Alastair, Norman and Neil for instance (sorry, cannot recall surnames atm). I suspect you are giving those you know about or can remember more credit than they deserve or would even claim.

      Delete